Mafia 11 Game

[texasjoshua]

Welcome to U.N. Mafia. You are an ambassador to a country of the world, you have gained power and prestige over the years and now world peace seems guaranteed. Or is it?

Recently several countries have been invaded by one or more other nations, for some strange reason we don't know who they are. Therefore as leader of the U.N. I officially declare it will be up to you, ambassadors of the U.N. to find the country(or country) and embargo(lynch) them for good!
Note: Country's were randomly assigned to spots and where not picked.

Special Rules:
Normal Mafia Rules apply except for these:
1. Lynching is called Embargoing
2. Night Kill is called invading.

Good Luck Everyone

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players
-CheeseLord
-Wesley
-Felixrain
-Yourter12
-hyperme
-Pewskeepski
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Julian
-Megadog
-Donny514
-Hammer Up!
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-The Voice of Limeaid
-Wesley
-Summer
-MegamanO
-RandomCommander

Dead Players
-

Deadline will be announced when conversation begins to die down.
Sending PM's now

[texasjoshua]

PM's have been sent, please reply too your PM. Send in all night Actions

It is now Night One

[texasjoshua]

]Welcome to U.N. Mafia. You are an ambassador to a country of the world, you have gained power and prestige over the years and now world peace seems guaranteed. Or is it?

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players
-CheeseLord
-Wesley
-Felixrain
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Pewskeepski
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Julian
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Hammer Up!
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-The Voice of Limeaid
-Summer
-RandomCommander

Dead Players
-

I am sorry for some confusion caused, Gigacat has replaced Hyperme not megamanO, and Wesley has replaced The Voice of Limeaid because of the inability for these characters to receive PM's , anyone seeking clarification on roles related to these characters please PM me. The problem which prevented Hyperme from playing has been solved, Hyperme will now play in the spot previously occupied by Donny514.

Day Begins February 1st 5:00PM Jamul Time

[texasjoshua]

OH no It seems as though HammerUp! has been invaded.

He was a normal townie.


Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley
-Felixrain
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Pewskeepski
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Julian
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-The Voice of Limeaid
-Summer
-RandomCommander

Dead Players
-HammerUp!

Wesley,Felixrain,Reccer6, and Megadog need to send in PM's!

It is Now day, Night will begin on February 6th

[moltanem2000]

Good morning (or whatever they'd be called in this particular theme) to all! this game has been a long time coming, so let us hope there aren't too many lurkers.

[CheeseLord]

Hello. On general principle, I will claim as mafia. Now that we've got that out of the way, does anyone have any inconsequential details that they'd like to turn into major discussion points? They seem to be the best way to get the conversation going.

[Megadog]

I hate the first day, it's always so hard to start...

[moltanem2000]

Well Cheeselord certainly made things interesting fast. there are 6 options I see here.

1) CheeseLord is Mafia, he is saying this to draw attention away from him by drawing attention to himself. I'm not going to bother going into detail about this; you get what I mean.

2) Cheeselord is a Jester, trying to get us to conclude that he is doing option 1) to win.

3) Cheeselord is Towny, he is once again trying to divert attention away from himself in order to not get lynched. this seems odd to me, because he as a towny would have been much safer playing it normal.

4) Some sort of power role (like the ones that force you to seem suspicious, talk garbled, etc.) not overly likely, but you never know.

5) He's just being Cheeselord, messing with us because he can and because watching us (mainly me right now) squirm is immensely more fun than being a towny. I actually find this to be highly likely, because saying such a thing is pretty useless in every other scenario (except maybe for jester).

6) As he hinted towards, Cheeselord just wants to stimulate conversation. seems like a bit of a big risk and confusion for this cause though. This could however be a pretty useful back-door for him to retreat to if things get ugly for him.

Also, I hate to say this, because it's never really fair. But Cheeselord is pretty well known as one of the best players on here, and like his pro friends, is subject to being night-killed-night-1. The fact that he's still alive is a tad suspicious, though what with all the newer members this isn't as likely as it would have been before.

[Julian]

I will take, while not actually believing it, Cheeselord's bait. As such, I am going to VOTE:CHEESELORD.

[hyperme]

CheeseLord stuff

I say we lynch him, just to be sure.

Or not. He might be a powerful power role with quite some power. Or a Bomb. Or Lynchproof. But who knows?

[megamanO]

Seems doubtful he would just come out and say he was mafia just to get the conversation going if he is mafia, as most games I've seen in the first day people will just kill anyone.

Probably just my newbieness talking though.

[Pewskeepski]

I will take, while not actually believing it, Cheeselord's bait. As such, I am going to VOTE:CHEESELORD.
I say we lynch him, just to be sure.

Or not. He might be a powerful power role with quite some power. Or a Bomb. Or Lynchproof. But who knows?
This jumping on CheeseLord is making me suspicious of you both :| (Unless your joking)

Does Hammer Up get a last gasp? Not that it would help much with him being normal townie, but still...

[bowserfan]

I doubt that if CheeseLord REALLY was mafia, he would shout it out blindly. :p

...thing is, CL does this in almost every game he is in. Maybe he does it to make people start talking?

[seamonkey]

yeah, he would. I have nothing much to add, but that was a good conversation starter. I'm not averse to lynching CL, but I am averse to lynching him day one, as he does this literally every game

[Gigacat]

I think that Cheeselord isnt all that suspicious but i will look out for Mafia like stuff from him. Blatantly saying that is quite commen from him as someone pointed out.

Seeing as this is day one and we have little evedence, i will Random VOTE: BOWSERFAN.

[Gigacat]

Sorry to double post, but i dont edit my mafia posts.

I wont be here for the next 2-3 days; i will be away for a sailing reggata.

[CheeseLord]

Good to know I can still stir up discussion.

No one's done anything particularly unusual thus far. Suspicious, of course, but not unusual. My immediate gut reaction is that hyperme and Pewskeepski both overreacted a little, but beyond that I don't have much to go on.

[bowserfan]

@Gigacat: I don't quite see how random voting would get us anywhere.

[hyperme]

@Gigacat: I don't quite see how random voting would get us anywhere.

Perhaps you are saying this because his vote landed on you? A random vote is a way of pushing for coonversation, like this one we are doing now. Bandwagoning on a random is also a way to find those who could be up to something.

[texasjoshua]

Votes

1-Cheeselord
1-Bowserfan

When deadline occurs it will be a No Lynch
Deadline is February 6th

[Pewskeepski]

Oh dear, I hope this isn't the beginning of a slow mafia game, But it's the first day and nobody is acting really suspicious :???:

And there are currently a few people who haven't posted yet:

-Wesley (Hasn't been on Hamumu since December)
-Reecer 6 (Hasn't been on Hamumu since December)
-Felixrain (Hasn't been on Hamumu since October)
-Yourter12 (Has been on, Just hasn't posted here)
-SpaceManiac (Has been on, Just hasn't posted here)

[megamanO]

Not surprising as Mafia 10 took forever.

Only suspicion I have is Julian, who was awfully quick for attacking Cheese for doing what he usually does.

[texasjoshua]

A reminder that deadline is very soon.
If an embargo is to be made it needs to be made within the next 10 hours.

[Megadog]

Hmm, we need to get something done today, or we lose a valuable lynch.

We have two 'suspects':
*Obviously CL, but this is like PE in most Mafia games, and is excusable.
*Molt, the only one who thought CL could actually Mafia. No, HM and Julian are not suspicious, they were clearly running along with the 'Joke'.

[CheeseLord]

For no reason other than to get the game going, Vote: Wesley. I'd rather not have lurkers bogging the game down.

[Pewskeepski]

If were going to get rid of lurkers, I think we should embargo Felixrain, I don't think he'll be coming on Hamumu anytime soon.

Vote: Felixrain

[seamonkey]

I agree with getting rid of lurkers, but we have a lot of replacements. just send all lurkers a pm, especially the ones who haven't been on since september, and lacking a reply pm, and some posts in the thread replace them. Just a suggestion to the host. Also lynching lurkers doesn't mean the mafia will lynch them as well, in fact they won't.

[Julian]

Lurkers are not a problem in a game with fast, strict deadlines. This is a game with fast, strict deadlines, but the one problem is no consensus defaults to keep alive - if no consensus defaults to kill whoever has the most votes or a random person in a tie, the game will continue with or without lurkers.

[moltanem2000]

Sorry 'folks, was at a convention all week-end, so that's why I've been absent from everywhere, was busy playing LoL and Armagetron all night long.

@Megadog: Don't hate just because I brought up every possibility no matter the likelihood! Seems like you're grasping at straws to me, for there are much more unlikely options but you focus on this one. Only saying good things about such a post would be far more suspicious imo.

Well, obviously now I'm a tad suspicious megadog, because, unless I'm missing something big here, this seems largely based on nothing of any substantialness. Though I can understand we're scrounging up all evidence possible, no-matter how small.

[Megadog]

You are the only other person who is suspicious.

At no point in time did I say I would lynch you/vote you, I'm about as suspicious as you as I suspect you are of me...

Anyways, we need to do something other than agree that we need to do something, but I don't see any way to do that apart from random vote, so...

RANDOM VOTE: GIGACAT

[texasjoshua]

Deadline!!!! Not enough votes have been reached to make it a embargo so no embargo is made.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley
-Felixrain
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Pewskeepski
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Julian
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-The Voice of Limeaid
-Summer
-RandomCommander

Dead Players
-HammerUp!

Wesley,Felixrain,Reccer6, and need to send in PM's!
Megadog has posted so I assume he PM was reached, if Wesley, Felixrain, or Reccer 6 do not post or reply to PM's by the end of the next day they will be replaced.

It is now NIGHT 2: day will begin on February 11th

[texasjoshua]

Strangely enough there have been no invasions. It is now DAY 2

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley
-Felixrain
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Pewskeepski
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Julian
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-Summer
-RandomCommander
-BunnyBot5000

Dead Players
-HammerUp!

Wesley,Felixrain,Reccer6, and need to send in PM's!
If Wesley, Felixrain, or Reccer 6 have not sent it PM's by Night 2 they will be replaced.

It is now Day 2: night will begin on February 18th

[Megadog]

Hmm, that be odd.

Maybe the doc got lucky, and blocked the right guy. If this is true, then we have a semi-guaranteed good guy if the doc is killed....

Anyways, we need to keep this game moving, so lets get to it....

[CheeseLord]

Well done on the doctor's part. Even so, I'd have to ask the doctor not to say who you've protected until absolutely necessary.

So, any leads thus far? My instincts say Megadog and/or moltanem is evil. That's a good enough reason for me to say both are probably townies. Aside from that, I've got nothing.

[megamanO]

No nightinvasion or we have a good doctor?

Interesting, but that doesn't get us anywhere.

[Pewskeepski]

Maybe the doc got lucky
Well done on the doctor's part.
No nightinvasion or we have a good doctor?
Either the above, or the mafia team is made up of lurkers :???:

I think it's possible that the host didn't get a reply. It wasn't until the deadline (A little after, actually) that Texasjoshua posted the results. This could mean the members of the mafia arelurkers, or they're trying to make it look like they're lurkers.

night will begin on February 18th
Hmm... Mafia 10 needed more deadlines, But mafia 11 seems to have to many :p

[hyperme]

A doctor, hmm? From the observations I have made, that looks good on the table. The mafia may have gone for CheeseLord, and the doctor stopped them. Why CL? The overtly complex 'Good player is alive therefore scum but is that a trick?' gambit can backfire.

However, the scum may be lurking lurkers who lurk. Of course, the chance of entire scum team lurking is quite low. But since most hosts don't ask for backup kills, this doesn't made many leads.

A final, unlikelier idea is that the target was nightkill proof, meaning the mafia lost a kill in a way they can not easily fix.

[Megadog]

Ooh, that is something I overlooked, a bulletproof townie...

I feel that, to get the game moving, we should try and get a hit today, and the concept of the godfather being a lurker is interesting, so random lurker VOTE: Wesley

[bowserfan]

I guess the best thing I can do is vote lurkers as well.
VOTE: Wesley

[hyperme]

While killing the lurkers may help, they will be getting replaced soon, and there is probably at least one other way the kill could of failed. A doctor is quite likely in a game this size, and other power roles can easily shutdown kills.

[Pewskeepski]

Ah yes, the godfather could indeed be a (And even 'the only') lurker.

I find it interesting that both CL and MD decided to random vote Wesley. Meh, probably just a coincidence. Anyway, I agree with Hyperme that Wesley will get replaced and thus, there's not much point in embargoing him. Youter12 and SM haven't posted in this thread at all, although SM has his reasons, Yourter12 just hasn't been on.

Who's The Voice of Limeaid? I've looked all around the website, and I can't find him :?:

[hyperme]

Who's The Voice of Limeaid? I've looked all around the website, and I can't find him :?:

One of those people who registers, signs up for a mafia game then evaporates.
Hosts really should only let people with 10+ posts sign up.

[Gigacat]

K, got back 24 hours before the night. (cause a day before night sounds wierd). Interesting with the kill-less night. Ideas: I think the doctor got lucky. But that still leaves why Hamer up was killed night one. Here is how i see it.

Night 1: Mafia random kill. Why? They are inexperienced? Mafia cop inspection? Other mafia role that does stuff like that? Bus Conductor? Just listing some ideas.

Night 2: Mafia choose to follow what people have been saying? I recall someone said that it was unusual the Cheeselord was still alive seeing his large exprerience. Pehaps they are inexperienced in mafia and followed the advice, but got doctered? Or perhaps they forgot to PM the night kill? Roleblocker? Bullet Proof?

There, done. And remember: WIFOM! Mabye they are double crossing us?

[Gigacat]

Interesting Fact: The voice of Limeaid Does not exist! He isnt on the Members List. (http://hamumu.com/forum/memberlist.php?ltr=T&pp=50&sort=username&order=asc) I tried to Dumb Page search him but no results. Also hasnt posted on the Sign up page. HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE??? Id like and explanation, TexasJoshua.

[Pewskeepski]

Interesting Fact: The voice of Limeaid Does not exist! He isnt on the Members List. (http://hamumu.com/forum/memberlist.php?ltr=T&pp=50&sort=username&order=asc) I tried to Dumb Page search him but no results. Also hasnt posted on the Sign up page. HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE??? Id like and explanation, TexasJoshua.
Indeed, and he did sign up because I remember the post, but it's not there anymore. The user is gone and the post is gone... He was most likely not just banned, but also removed. That's what Jamul does with spam bots.

Anywho... Uh... I don't have anything more to say... :(

[texasjoshua]

Interesting Fact: The voice of Limeaid Does not exist! He isnt on the Members List. (http://hamumu.com/forum/memberlist.php?ltr=T&pp=50&sort=username&order=asc) I tried to Dumb Page search him but no results. Also hasnt posted on the Sign up page. HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE??? Id like and explanation, TexasJoshua.

Strange, I'll be sure to remove him from the list, thanks for the heads up.

[Gigacat]

K, thanks

[moltanem2000]

Bah, been busy with life/being sick. Anyways, just here to say </lurk> and let yall know I'm still here :P don't have anything to point out in particular, I can't quite grasp half of what's going on.

It seems no-one's presented themselves as super-scummy thus far, so we don't have much to work with (though apparently I'm scummy, I still don't see how pointing out all possibilities, both good and bad, makes me suspicious). Decidedly this deadline thing is working against the townies. The Maf missed their shot last night so let's try to make today count.

Let's not forget cheeselord, he has done the most odd thing so far, as easy as it is to go "meh, that's CL, he does that all the time" I think we should be discussing his purity far more than the small bit of discussion I brought up about it.

[Pewskeepski]

I feel that, to get the game moving, we should try and get a hit today, and the concept of the godfather being a lurker is interesting, so random lurker VOTE: Wesley
I guess the best thing I can do is vote lurkers as well.
VOTE: Wesley
Wesley, Felixrain, and Reecer6 will get replaced. I say we embargo Youter12 because he is lurking, and won't get replaced.

Vote: Yourter12

[texasjoshua]

Votes Wesley-2
Yourter 12-1
Deadline is soon, 8 to lynch.

[Pewskeepski]

Wait a sec...
Bah, been busy with life/being sick. Anyways, just here to say </lurk> and let yall know I'm still here :P don't have anything to point out in particular, I can't quite grasp half of what's going on.
You were sick and thus, you couldn't get on the computer. This has opened the possibility that you were the 'lurking godfather'. I'll be keeping an eye on you.

[seamonkey]

Really? to be honest (while I haven't checked his activities on the site) I believe him. It's common. (not to say I'm not open to him being mafia, but at the same time that really isn't a particularly suspicious thing)

[CheeseLord]

In the interest of creating useful conversation, I will Vote: Pewskeepski. Also, for good measure, I'll continue to claim as mafia.

Thoughts?

[texasjoshua]

Votes: Wesley-2
Yourter 12-1
Pewskeepski-1
Deadline is soon, 8 to lynch.

[Gigacat]

C'mon guys, we need to lynch someone before the deadline comes! I see Pewskeepskis point and shall Vote: Yourter12 simply because if we don't, the mafia get a free kill.

[Megadog]

Pewkeepski seems to be grabbing at straws a bit too much, and so I VOTE: PEWKEEPSKI. I mean, come on, he's trying to make Molt look like the godfather, I just said he was suspicious. (And seriously Molt, I said suspicious, stop making it seem like I was trying to get people to lynch you!)

[moltanem2000]

Wait a sec...

You were sick and thus, you couldn't get on the computer. This has opened the possibility that you were the 'lurking godfather'. I'll be keeping an eye on you.

It's called a bad case of the flu? don't know if you've ever had that, but I was in bed for 3 days, if I was this "lurking godfather", I would be lurking, not posting and making a big deal about having been lurking.

Vote: pewskeepski whatisthisIdon't even (yes, that is my reason and I stand by it)

[hyperme]

Saying the main Mafia dude is a lurker implies TJ doesn't know how to host a game and set a backup kill sender. I'd be more suspious of anyone who doesn't needed an anti-lurk PM, but hasn't posted. Like Yourter, perhaps.

Since Pewskeepski isn't ingoring a purposful lurker while while saying 'kill the non-lurker who had a reason for not posting' I feel safe in saying

VOTE: Pewskeepski

[bowserfan]

Ya know, I kinda hate revoting because I have to think up something smart to say + a reason, but I guess I will do it just once.

UNVOTE

VOTE: Pewskeepski before the deadline strikes.

[Pewskeepski]

Well, what I said certainly sparked up discussion. But in the wrong way :(. I don't like slow games, people were just Voting for random people and we weren't getting any where by being 'normal' so I decided to do something (stupid) anti-normal. I just tossed out a brief idea that I didn't wholeheartedly believe. I was mainly looking to see how people would react to it. Accusing someone of something can sometimes work because If it's true, they'll react in a certain way. Nobody reacted they way that I was looking for so I'm no longer suspicious of Molt.

I'm relatively new to mafia (This is my second game.) And I guess my playing strategy is just suspicious.

Mark my words though, If you embargo me you'll be worse off then you would be if we didn't make an embargo.

[hyperme]

If you embargo me you'll be worse off then you would be if we didn't make an embargo.

Sure we will. I mean you're not just saying that as a vain attempt to not get lynched? Oh wait, you probably are.

PROTIP: Saying that lynching you will put the town at a disadvantage without any other information makes you look pretty evil.

[texasjoshua]

Deadline!!!! Thanks to beracracy not enough votes have been reached to make it a embargo so no embargo is made.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer
-Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Pewskeepski
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Julian
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana


Dead Players
-HammerUp!

Wesley,Felixrain,Reccer6 replacments are recieving there PM's now and should be in the game by day 3.
If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.

It is now NIGHT 3: day will begin on February 23th

[texasjoshua]

Ok, the replacement PM's are just now sent, any reference to Felixrain, Wesley, or Reccer 6 should now be directed to there replacements.(check above) Replacements please remember to reply to your PM's-

Thank you,
The Management

[texasjoshua]

Oh no it appears as though Julian has been invaded, he was china, he had the power of a one shot vote control. (remember you do have a last gasp)

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer
-Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Pewskeepski
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
-Julian

BunnyBot500, and Summer need to send in PM's
If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.

It is now Day 3: night will begin on March 3rd

[Julian]

All I have to say is: D:

[yourter12]

We have losing! D:

[bowserfan]

We have losing! D:
After days of inactivity... is that... all you have to say?

...

[Gigacat]

C'mon guyts, we need action! Yourter12 has finally posted and the one post hee has made has been filled with no news, nfo, ligit opinions or ides. therefore, FOS: Yourter 12

[hyperme]

We have losing! D:

Yeah this is probably a way to try and look less lurkerly. You really should contribute. Since you're activly lurking

VOTE: Yourter12

Until he is explaining himself.

[bowserfan]

(Also, thoughts about that quote: ''We have losing! D:'' --)



''We have losing'', besides intentional (or not) bad grammar, could mean two different things depending on which side (townie or mafia) Yourter12 is on;
If he is a townie, then here is a message to him: we likely wouldn't be losing if you should had contributed something earlier (or even now). :p (not very likely)
He and the other mafias are losing because they don't seem to find and kill the doctor, or any other powah roles. (more likely)
So with my possibly longest mafia post made, I shall...
VOTE: Yourter12
Shall he bring up evidence of him being townie (in a way that he does not exactly reveal what role he is (that would make him an easy target for the mafia)), I will unvote him.

[Pewskeepski]

Vote: Yourter12 For reasons that have been stated over the past couple of days.

[Pewskeepski]

Double post to avoid editing:

Yourter12 hasn't contributed to this game, so why would he try to look less lurky? Probably because he's mafia, and doesn't want to let his buddy's down.

[RandomCommander]

(Also, thoughts about that quote: ''We have losing! D:'' --)



''We have losing'', besides intentional (or not) bad grammar, could mean two different things depending on which side (townie or mafia) Yourter12 is on;
If he is a townie, then here is a message to him: we likely wouldn't be losing if you should had contributed something earlier (or even now). :p (not very likely)
He and the other mafias are losing because they don't seem to find and kill the doctor, or any other powah roles. (more likely)
So with my possibly longest mafia post made, I shall...
VOTE: Yourter12
Shall he bring up evidence of him being townie (in a way that he does not exactly reveal what role he is (that would make him an easy target for the mafia)), I will unvote him.

Those are both very possible, however, just because someone lurks around for a while and then finally makes a post without stating anything but "oh noes we are losing!" doesn't mean he is instantaneously suspicious. Right now though:

Vote: Yourter12 for lack of anyone else to vote on for being suspicious.

P.S: What's so bad about editing?

[texasjoshua]

Votes

Yourter 12- 4: Random Commander, Pewskeepski, bowserfan, and hyperme.

7 votes to lynch

[moltanem2000]

wait... what? Am I the only one finding none of this makes sense? I mean, sure, yourter12 trying to sneak into the game without acknowledging his lurking and not making any sense is suspicious, but I find most of your reasoning to be equally confusing.

Yourter12 hasn't contributed to this game, so why would he try to look less lurky? Probably because he's mafia, and doesn't want to let his buddy's down.
Pewskeepski just jumps the bandwagon, then 10 minutes later decides it might be a good idea to show some reason for doing so, but just makes matters worse. How does saying "we have loosing D:" help his mafia buddies? If yourter12 was mafia, I see no reason why he would ruin the great thing he had going for him. (everyone pretty much forgetting he was in the game). Who's to say he isn't posting to not let his town buddies down?

Yourter12 may have posted something suspicious today, but pewskeepski has baffled me 2 days in a row, so I will re-initiate my vote against Pewskeepski

[megamanO]

Out of anything he could have said yourter says that we are losing? Now that is suspicious.

While Pewskeepski was acting strange yesterday, yourter's post seems more so.

vote: yourter12

[Pewskeepski]

I came up with an idea 10 minutes after I posted, so I posted again. Yourter12 has contributed nothing to this game even if he's alive, so why would he care if we killed him? It's not like the ability to play is a real loss to him. And nobody was 'forgetting' that he was in the game.
What's so bad about editing?
People could use editing to change what they say, which can make them look suspicious.

[megamanO]

If anyone had read his post within that 10 minutes only to later find he changed it, that would look bad on him.

[texasjoshua]

Votes

Yourter 12- 5: Random Commander, Pewskeepski, bowserfan, and hyperme, megamanO
Pewskeepski-1:moltanem5000

7 votes to lynch

[RandomCommander]

Molt has a point, If we jump Yourter just becuase he immediately went out of lurking, we only have a small chance of taking out one of the mafia members, because we have no evidence of him being suspicious, due to his lurkitude. I know i am risking another tie lynch, but i think we should go vote pewkeepski due to his actions yesterday, he actually presents evidence of his suspicion.

So i will Un-Vote, and then Vote: Pewkeepski.

[BunnyBot 5000]

I've looked over the posts and such. I hereby determine Pewskeepski the mafia. Yourter is just a lurker. Townies lurk all the time. I mean jeez.
VOTE: PEWKEEPSKI

[texasjoshua]

Votes

Yourter 12- 4: , Pewskeepski, bowserfan, and hyperme, megamanO
Pewskeepski-3:moltanem5000,Random Commander, BunnyBot5000

7 votes to lynch

[hyperme]

I hereby determine Pewskeepski the mafia. Yourter is just a lurker. Townies lurk all the time. I mean jeez.


Please explain your logic before I am forced to assume that both you and Yourter are Mafia, as you seem to just be bandwagoning on Day 3.

Furthermore, you're definatly no my no play list for when I'm hosting games. Lurking only damges games, and an attitude like that won't help. In fact, in comes off as a very weak defence of someone on your team.

[Pewskeepski]

I feel like there's a target on my back... (Gee, I wonder why?) :roll:

I have no actual proof I'm not mafia. (But then again, who does?)

Pewkeepski seems to be grabbing at straws a bit too much, and so I VOTE: PEWKEEPSKI. I mean, come on, he's trying to make Molt look like the godfather, I just said he was suspicious. (And seriously Molt, I said suspicious, stop making it seem like I was trying to get people to lynch you!)
At first, I voted Felixrain - for my reasons, but I didn't know he would get replaced so I voted Yourter12 the next day - for my reasons. Did I ever vote Moltanem? No. I just threw the idea out there to stir things up.

It's called a bad case of the flu? don't know if you've ever had that, but I was in bed for 3 days, if I was this "lurking godfather", I would be lurking, not posting and making a big deal about having been lurking.

Vote: pewskeepski whatisthisIdon't even (yes, that is my reason and I stand by it)
There's such thing as reversed psychology. And I'm no more suspicious of you than Megadog is. "I'll be keeping an eye on you" isn't much of an accusation. I said "This has opened the possibility that you're the godfather." I didn't say "You are the godfather."

Saying the main Mafia dude is a lurker implies TJ doesn't know how to host a game and set a backup kill sender. I'd be more suspious of anyone who doesn't needed an anti-lurk PM, but hasn't posted. Like Yourter, perhaps.

Since Pewskeepski isn't ingoring a purposful lurker while while saying 'kill the non-lurker who had a reason for not posting' I feel safe in saying

VOTE: Pewskeepski
I never said "kill the non-lurker who had a reason for not posting." I held my vote on Yourter because I didn't have any evidence (Just a theory) against Molt.

Sure we will. I mean you're not just saying that as a vain attempt to not get lynched? Oh wait, you probably are.

PROTIP: Saying that lynching you will put the town at a disadvantage without any other information makes you look pretty evil.
What do you call this?
Well, what I said certainly sparked up discussion. But in the wrong way . I don't like slow games, people were just Voting for random people and we weren't getting any where by being 'normal' so I decided to do something (stupid) anti-normal. I just tossed out a brief idea that I didn't wholeheartedly believe. I was mainly looking to see how people would react to it. Accusing someone of something can sometimes work because If it's true, they'll react in a certain way. Nobody reacted they way that I was looking for so I'm no longer suspicious of Molt.
PROTIP: Read everything that's posted.
I hereby determine Pewskeepski the mafia.
How? Please explain...

[seamonkey]

is it just me or has this day been a massive bandwagon?
few things
1. @randomcommander editing is bad because if someone says something incredible incriminating of themselves, then somebody points it out they can go back and edit it out and go "what are you talking about I didn't say that" then large debates will ensue about said saying (confusing, but long story short, it's bad)
2. This debate about "I officially declare him mafia" is slightly absurd. Fine I declare pewskeepski innoc*paradox eats up everything*

[Megadog]

Thanks for reminding me I was suspicious of you 'Yesterday'

How I felt yesterday, along with the ample suspicions of today, make me feel safe in VOTE(ing): PEWKEEPSKI again.

[texasjoshua]

Votes

Yourter 12- 5: Pewskeepski, bowserfan, hyperme, megamanO,Gigacat
Pewskeepski-4:moltanem5000,Random Commander, BunnyBot5000,Megadog

7 votes to lynch

[Gigacat]

What i find is suspicious is that Yourter12 Hasnt defended him/herself. When 4/7 votes ae on you, shouldnt you at leat protect yourself? Therefore i vote: Yourter12.

[moltanem2000]

it's not too suspicious per say, I mean, he's been lurking almost the whole game, so for him to go back to that isn't too ground-breaking. Though it certainly is food for thought, I think the likeliest scenario is he hasn't checked the game since saying what he said.

Not to be protective towards yourter, he's right after pewskeepski in my list of suspects. Just saying; lurkers gunna lurk

[CheeseLord]

At this point, I'm much more in favor of Pewskeepski being mafia. Lurkers are annoying, of course, but I'm much more comfortable voting for someone who has actually acted evil than someone who hasn't acted at all. Vote: Pewskeepski.

[hyperme]

While Yourter is being lurkful, Pewhoweveryouspellit has said some pretty scumtastic things, mainly the 'you'll regret lynchin' me' thing. So it's time to

Vote: Pewskeepski

For great justice.

HOWEVER!

BB5000 and Yourter are on my 'could be eviltastic' list.


And lurking should be banned I say! Banned!

[bowserfan]

Fine, guess I will UNVOTE and VOTE: Pewskeepski as well.

However! If Pewskeepski isn't mafia, I'll resume to attempting to lynch Yourter. I advise you to do that too if that happens.

[texasjoshua]

And a lynch is finally made, Pewskipski is dead!
He was a townie, he had the power to steal power from the dead!

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer
-Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-pewskeepski(he knows no important secrets)


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
--Pewskeepski
--Julian


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.
Summer has a warning for no Pm sent in yet.

It is now NIGHT 4: day will begin on March 4th

[texasjoshua]

BunnyBot5000 is dead!!! He was invaded.
He was the doctor, he could protect one country each night(remember all players get last gasp's) Edited: for clarification purposes BunnyBot is not the doctor but gets a vigilant kill(and he is town)

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer
-Yourter12
-MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-pewskeepski(he knows no important secrets)


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
--Pewskeepski
--Julian
--Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.
Summer has a warning for no Pm sent in yet.

It is now Day 4: night will begin on March 10th

[RandomCommander]

i just want to say one thing:

DANG!!!!

Alright for my suspicions: hyperme (BB5000 was on the evil list for him) with low evil, and yourter12 (keepin my eye on him) with medium evil.

Going to see what other people think before voting.

[BunnyBot 5000]

My PM said that I was not a doctor, but I could kill someone with my last gasp. If this is a mistake, darn. If not, VIGILANTKILL: Yourter12.
I have nothing else to contribute.

[hyperme]

Alright for my suspicions: hyperme (BB5000 was on the evil list for him

I explain why BB500 was the evil - he said Pewhoweveritgoes was evil without citing his evidense.

On more pressing matters, CL still isn't dead, Yourter is ignoring the game, and BB5000 might just be about to vapourize Yourter.

[moltanem2000]

I'll wait to see if yourter12 has actually been killed before I ponder endlessly over suspicions. Other than that I still find Cheeselord a tad suspicious, mainly because he would seem to be toying with us a bit.

[texasjoshua]

My PM said that I was not a doctor, but I could kill someone with my last gasp. If this is a mistake, darn. If not, VIGILANTKILL: Yourter12.
I have nothing else to contribute.(oops your right, looked at the wrong person)

Revised: BunnyBot5000 is dead, upon death he can retaliate upon another nation! Killing them.

BunnyBot kills Yourter12 and is lucky!

Yourter twelve is dead! He was a mafia role-cop! He could investigate a normal country's power every other night.

[texasjoshua]

Yourter 12 has been killed!
He was a mafia role-cop(as explained above).

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer
-MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-pewskeepski(he knows no important secrets)


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
--Pewskeepski
--Julian
--Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000
-Yourter12(mafia)


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.
Summer has a warning for no Pm sent in yet.

It is still Day 4: night will begin on March 10th

6 votes required to lynch

[RandomCommander]

so he WAS evil! well good job BB5000!

So following the agenda of hyperme, yeah it still seems that CL isn't dead and is still toying with us. I guess i'll take the bait that has been lying around and aging for awhile.

VOTE:CheeseLord

[CheeseLord]

Well, that changes things significantly. I was all set to mourn the loss of the doctor, but I'm much happier with this turn of events. It's always nice to have a little extra margin for error.

Now, I find it interesting that people are accusing me, but not entirely unusual. That happens on an astonishingly regular basis, just because I don't die on the first night. My gut reaction is that Hyperme and Moltanem genuinely suspect me, and that RandomCommander is just using that as an excuse to go after me. None of them is quite suspicious enough to accuse, though.

I'd actually be a little surprised if I haven't been inspected by now. As always, I'll ask the cop not to claim unless it's clear that I'm not going to talk my way out of it (and, of course, you've actually inspected me).

[RandomCommander]

My gut reaction is that Hyperme and Moltanem genuinely suspect me, and that RandomCommander is just using that as an excuse to go after me. None of them is quite suspicious enough to accuse, though.

When i say "I guess i'll take the bait that has been lying around and aging for awhile", i mean that i am going to take a risk based on past turns (days) that have evidence of suspicion. Hyperme bringing this up reminds us of this, and thus enables some of us to make a secondary descision (i say secondary because it is not that important in a way only i understand for some reason.), either to take a plunge and lynch this guy who might have falsely claimed as mafia, or to simply ignore this oppritunity and probably not get a lynch.

I'm taking this option half of, yes, you're right, using hyperme's suspicion as an excuse, and the other half for another, logical reason, which had a chance to deny that first half.

I stand with my vote.

[Gigacat]

Just posting some stuff ive noticed:

Megadog:

Hmm, we need to get something done today, or we lose a valuable lynch.

We have two 'suspects':
*Obviously CL, but this is like PE in most Mafia games, and is excusable.
*Molt, the only one who thought CL could actually Mafia. No, HM and Julian are not suspicious, they were clearly running along with the 'Joke'.


Has already been bought up.. Molt had just posted all the reasons of CLs claim, then Julian votes CL because of it, yet megadog sill thinks of molt as suspicious.

You are the only other person who is suspicious. (this is directed at molt)

At no point in time did I say I would lynch you/vote you, I'm about as suspicious as you as I suspect you are of me...

Anyways, we need to do something other than agree that we need to do something, but I don't see any way to do that apart from random vote, so...

RANDOM VOTE: GIGACAT

Still tries to attack molt a little bit. Then random votes me 30 minutes before the deadline saying things needed to be done, when a) i had no votes on me and it was unlikely that his vote would contribute to me getting killed. and b) he could have voted someone with more votes to try to actually get a lynch. I understand that he probably random voted me to get a reaction, which i have now given him. If so, why not do it the next day.

Bowserfan:

@Gigacat: I don't quite see how random voting would get us anywhere.

He has been playing mafia long enough to know the purpose of a random vote... Anyhow, not very suspicious.

Megadog again:

Hmm, that be odd.

Maybe the doc got lucky, and blocked the right guy. If this is true, then we have a semi-guaranteed good guy if the doc is killed....

Anyways, we need to keep this game moving, so lets get to it....

What do you mean by that?? As i see it, he is saying that he will have an advantage if the doc is killed by having a "good guy". I know i probably totally mis-interperated that, but that is how i see it.

A total of 4 people then bandwagon on CLs vote they are:
Megadog
MoltanM
HyperMe
Bowserfan.

Band wagoning is slightly suspicious, although this time there was a proper(ish) reason for it.

Yourter12:

We have losing! D:

Yourters first post. Totally useless post. I already posted about that though.

Out of time, ill hopefully post more analysis soon.

[Gigacat]

Just to clarify: CLs vote was on pewskeepski.

[Megadog]

I meant the doctor knows who he protected, and so if he dies, he may or may not choose to tell us who he protected, depending on if they are looking like they will be lynched (assuming they protected a townie)

[hyperme]

Gigicat, Yourter is both Mafia and dead.

Furthermore, Pewhowyouspellit was acting in a mafia-likeway will the 'I is an important role' business.

And a list of peeps the doctor protected won't help, as any player can be protected.

Also, if there is a cop, remeber to post you're inspection results if killed.

[texasjoshua]

Votes

Cheeselord-1 vote- RandomComander

6 to lynch.
Also to clarify confusion with PM's Donny514 has been replaced by Hyperme and refrences to Hyperme in PM's are invalid and have been replaced by other players. Any questions should be Pm'd to me.

We apologize for any confusion caused, thank you
The Management

[moltanem2000]

A total of 4 people then bandwagon on CLs vote they are:
Megadog
MoltanM
HyperMe
Bowserfan.

Band wagoning is slightly suspicious, although this time there was a proper(ish) reason for it.

It's not band-wagoning if you have legitimate reasons for your vote and clearly expressed them

[Megadog]

And a list of peeps the doctor protected won't help, as any player can be protected
I had come to the conclusion that doctors knew who they protected each night, and with a night having a no-kill, we may have the mafia's target from that night.

[texasjoshua]

Once again I am afraid to point out that BunnyBot5000 was not the doctor but a Vigilant. The doctor is not yet dead.

We apologize for the confusion

[texasjoshua]

Sorry for the delay(Spring Break)

Not enough votes have been made to make it an embargo so there is no players dead.
Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer
---MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-pewskeepski

Dead Players
-HammerUp!
--Pewskeepski
--Julian
- Yourter12
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.
Summer has a warning for no Pm sent in yet. Space Maniac has a warning for no posts made.

It is now NIGHT 5: day will begin on March 18th

[texasjoshua]

It has been decided that because of spring break deadline will be extended till March 20th

[texasjoshua]

It is now day. (No one bother commenting on my lack of information, it is not a mistake.)


Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer
---MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements
-Anandrana
-pewskeepski

Dead Players
-HammerUp!
--Pewskeepski
--Julian
- Yourter12
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.
Summer has a warning for no Pm sent in yet. Space Maniac has a warning for no posts made.(in awhile)

It is now Day 5: night will begin on March 28th

[Gigacat]

Shoop da Woop! no deaths!. Anyhow, no new information from me.

[RandomCommander]

Thank god the doctor's still alive! He got lucky again! Or is it one of the lurkers?

[megamanO]

Good doctor. Niceness.

[Megadog]

Actually, because of the length of the night, I'm leaning away from the doctor saving someone. I think the godfather is lurking...

This is just a hunch of course, so don't take it as cold hard evidence (against me or anyone else...)

[moltanem2000]

unless of course the doctor took his time to send in his post. Just sayin'.

[Megadog]

unless of course the doctor took his time to send in his post. Just sayin'.
Point taken...

[Pewskeepski]

Am I the only one who noticed that megamanO has three dashes in front of his name? Molt and BB5000 don't have any. Me and Julian have two, and Yourter has a space :???:

I believe the lengthly night also might be TJ waiting until he HAS to post. Maybe.

If I was to say that anybody was evil, I would say Megadog because he has been saying "We need to get this game moving!" and yet, he doesn't follow his statement very well. He also has a history of random voting.

Hyperme seemed to be twisting my words around when there was a target on myself, not much of a suspicion thing, but strange.

Fare well... townies.... kill..... the...... mafia.......

(Pewskeepski is officially dead)

[RandomCommander]

Okay, finally! some information!

Megadog, yes, i notice he has a history of Random Voting, but i think that's just normal for a player. Random Voting is usually done where there was NO evidence for almost half of the day, which i was about to do now. Megadog is only just using a strategy, and that doesn't mean he is automatically suspicious.

Hyperme, on the other hand, twisting around words is a tad suspicious to me. That's usually one of the signs of mafia. I will keep my eye on him.

That is all.

[hyperme]

I'd like to know how I'm twisting words. Pointing out people's failure to appear innocent is hrdly twisting. If you make a post such as 'If you lynch my you'll regret it', you aren't helping. It is my fault you chose until your death knell to bring up a potention power role.

And please, RC, check my posts before parrotting the words of the dead. Actualy, this is basically what I've just said.

So, in short, provide evidense of this word twisting.

[RandomCommander]

Sure we will. I mean you're not just saying that as a vain attempt to not get lynched? Oh wait, you probably are.

PROTIP: Saying that lynching you will put the town at a disadvantage without any other information makes you look pretty evil.

That is an example: When Pew said that we would be better off not lynching at all instead of lynching him (or something like that). But your right, That kind of "Twisting words" Isn't really a "Suspicious" Type of twisting...

And i wasn't parroting Pew's Words...I was taking his statements and adding my thoughts to it (notice how i denied Megadog of being suspicious instead of supporting it.) I only said i was going to keep my eye on you, i didn't just say "i shuold vote him because of some illogical reason based on this evidence!", so please calm down for a sec, because my suspicion is off, now that i double checked!

[megamanO]

[LAST_GASP]

Am I the only one who noticed that megamanO has three dashes in front of his name?


I had nothing to do with it!

[Megadog]

I am finding myself wondering what MMO said BEFORE his post was edited, and feel like that may have not been a good move, as a mafia or otherwise...

[CheeseLord]

Sorry I haven't posted much. I've been really swamped with work this week.

In the interest of full disclosure, I will mention that I was roleblocked last night. Draw from that whatever conclusions you will. I'm not shocked that I was blocked last night, although I am a bit surprised that I wasn't targeted sooner.

My primary suspicions at the moment are hyperme and RandomCommander. They seem to be in the process of distancing themselves from each other without actually accusing each other, which is usually what I do when I'm evil.

[Megadog]

I suspect that someone will point out soon that the mafia was roleblocked.

I, however, see no point in CL coming out with this were he mafia, so I still assume he is town.

[moltanem2000]

I'm personally leaning more towards him being a jester. All his shenanigans make sense when you see him as a jester.

[megamanO]

My quote looked funny.

My skills in forum posting are not the greatest.

[texasjoshua]

And deadline no votes=no embargo which = no deaths!

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana
-MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
-Pewskeepski
-Julian
- Yourter12
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.

PM's for replacing SM and Summer are going out now

It is now Night 6: day will begin on April 3rd

[texasjoshua]

Strangely enough no country has been invaded! Again! The Invading Countries must be lying low tonight.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana
-MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
-Pewskeepski
-Julian
- Yourter12
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.
6 to embargo!

It is now Day 6: night will begin on April 10th

[moltanem2000]

Back from Skiing for 4 days, sorry, probably should have mentioned that. Anyways, this is what, the second night in a row with no deaths? I'd say this either means;

1) Mafia is lurker(s)
2) Mafia is active, wants us to lynch lurkers by assuming 1) is true

so yeah.

[Gigacat]

Vote: Cheeselord.

Why? Because cheeselord posted yesterday that he was roleblocked. There were no night kills that night. then (in theory) the roleblocker blocks cheeselord again. And again, no night kills. So cheeselord is mafia, being blocked and thus no night kills.

[CheeseLord]

I will, for the sake of completeness, say that I was roleblocked again last night. I will also point out that I was not roleblocked the second night, when there was also no kill. Presumably I've been inspected by now, so there's at least one person out there who can attest to my innocence (please don't, though, unless it's clear I'm going to be lynched otherwise).

I find it odd that both Gigacat and moltanem missed the possibility of a doctor. Of course, Gigacat has essentially claimed as the roleblocker, and I'd be surprised if there are any counterclaims, so I don't particularly suspect him. I'd be more inclined to suspect moltanem, but I'll hold my vote until we get a discussion going.

[moltanem2000]

oh right doctors. Well I don't really have anything to say in my defense, though I'll point out that the likelihood of a doctor getting a successful save twice in a row is pretty darn low, whether (s)he knows what they're doing or not, so I still think mafia shenanigans are more likely. But yeah, that's definitely a possibility.

[Pewskeepski]

CheeseLord saying he's been blocked on two days, when there has been no night kill on either of them, seems... dumb. Almost everyone in this game has stated that CheeseLord is a good player so he could be trying to look like an innocent townie by saying something that would make him appear to have nothing to hide. I'm not saying CheeseLord is mafia, but it certainly is weird that he, with his record of profession, would say something like that :???:

Gigacat has essentially claimed as the roleblocker, and I'd be surprised if there are any counterclaims, so I don't particularly suspect him. I'd be more inclined to suspect moltanem, but I'll hold my vote until we get a discussion going.
His post didn't look like a claim to me. Just sayin :|

Oh yeah, I'd also like to state that I'm not Pewskeepski, I'm SpaceManiac in disguise.

[CheeseLord]

His post didn't look like a claim to me. Just sayin :|
If it wasn't a claim, I'd like to know how he knew I was roleblocked before I stated it.

[Pewskeepski]

Then (in theory) the roleblocker blocks cheeselord again. And again, no night kills.
Well, now that I notice it...
So cheeselord is mafia, being blocked and thus no night kills.
...I suppose this does sound like a statement.

[RandomCommander]

I say we do a little experiment:

We lynch nobody, so during the night, the roleblocker (whoever he/she is...) will block cheeselord again. It will be very, VERY unlikely that the doctor will get a save three times in a row, much less two. The next night will determine CL's innocence. I say it's a fair experiment.

And yes, this actually does mean i am suspicious of CL. I just want to blurt that out.

[CheeseLord]

And this plan would distinguish me from a lurker mafia how? Or a godfather who decides not to kill in order to frame me, for that matter? The problem with plans like that is that once the mafia know about them, it becomes remarkably easy to circumvent them.

[RandomCommander]

Like i said, it is only an experiment. If they are lurker mafia, they won't do anything to circumvent this "plan." If, for the third night, there is no kill AND you get roleblocked again, we just have to be careful, because, you're right, anything can be possible.

[Megadog]

I honestly trust CL on this one. I see no reason for him to admit to being roleblocked like this if he was mafia. This makes me suspicious of GC, who is either the roleblocker, or a mafia playing him...(assuming CL ISN'T mafia)

[seamonkey]

I kinda trust CL. He could be claiming to be blocked (and being blocked assuming he's telling th truth), could just be a ploy to throw off suspicion, but at the same time it could be legit.

[RandomCommander]

Wait, sorry for being slow, but i just realised:
The roleblocker probably IS part of the mafia! So scratch that experiment, I am going to remove my suspicion of CL.

Gigacat being mafia: Not likely. How does Voting CL make a mark of GC's suspicion? He just only made a legit reason, Thus having a chance he is innocent. I would want MD to explain how he thinks GC is suspicious.

[Pewskeepski]

A mafia roleblocker? Possible. After all, there was a mafia cop. However, I think it very likely that he can only block every other night. Just like the cop.

[seamonkey]

whats the ev for a mafia roleblocker. 1 mafia power role makes the mafia side pretty strong, two would be insane. Why do you say this with such firmness? (it's possible, i would like to hear the reasoning for the probably part)

[Pewskeepski]

This game seems to have a lot of power roles, I say this because Julian (Vote controller), Pewskeepski (Power stealer), Bunnybot5000 (Vigilant killer), and Youter12 (Mafia copper) have all had unique ability's and because of that, I think the mafia could have power roles too. I used the word 'possible' because of the obvious fact, which you pointed out - It would make the mafia insanely strong.

[seamonkey]

actually I am with you. My last comment was directed towards mainly randomcommander

[hyperme]

This game seems to have a lot of power roles, I say this because Julian (Vote controller), Pewskeepski (Power stealer), Bunnybot5000 (Vigilant killer), and Youter12 (Mafia copper) have all had unique ability's and because of that, I think the mafia could have power roles too. I used the word 'possible' because of the obvious fact, which you pointed out - It would make the mafia insanely strong.

Many town power roles would suggest Mafia powers. A Godfather is likely, as well as some other power. Role Blocker seems likely, but something else could be there instead. Or, of course, the game is unbalenced towards the town, but thats very unlikely.

[Megadog]

Wait, sorry for being slow, but i just realised:
The roleblocker probably IS part of the mafia! So scratch that experiment, I am going to remove my suspicion of CL.

Gigacat being mafia: Not likely. How does Voting CL make a mark of GC's suspicion? He just only made a legit reason, Thus having a chance he is innocent. I would want MD to explain how he thinks GC is suspicious.
Gigacat assumed CL was roleblocked again last night, before CL said he was. To have this kind of inside information, he must have either been the roleblocker, or a mafia trying to play him. Now that the idea of a mafia roleblocker is coming up, Gigacat is looking even more suspicious, without actually having said anything more.

[Gigacat]

The reason i voted Cheeselord is because I thought some stuff (see my quote). I never said in my post that i knew Cheeselord was blocked, it was just an idea. That i stand by.

[texasjoshua]

Once Again there is no embargo due to not enough votes, if this continues the number of votes required will begin to drop.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
-Pewskeepski
-Julian
- Yourter12
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me. We are now looking for a replacement for Anandrana.


It is now Night 7: day will begin on April 15th

[texasjoshua]

Elmikkino has replaced Wesley, and all his replacements.

[texasjoshua]

Much to everyone surprise no countries were invaded last night.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-MegamanO
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat

Replacements


Dead Players
-HammerUp!
-Pewskeepski
-Julian
- Yourter12
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.


It is now Day 7: night will begin on April 22nd.
6 to lynch

[megamanO]

Surprise? Nobody was killed. Again.

[Pewskeepski]

Once again there are 3 options:
Lurking Mafia
Blocked Mafia
Protected Victim (Unlikely)

Unless the mafia continue their embarrassing lack of invasions, we should make an effort to take them out. So let's get a discussion going, and stop talking about how or why the mafia aren't killing anybody.

[CheeseLord]

I was blocked once again. Odd.

I know I'm not evil, and I don't think the doctor is that lucky, so that just leaves a lurker mafia. I'd support killing lurkers until we find the mafia. Clearly, the rest of you can't be sure I'm not evil, so I'm probably still a good target too.

[Megadog]

I can see a way for the role blocker to prove CL is innocent, or guilty, but explaining it would make it pointless, as it would no longer work. I just hope our roleblocker can work out what he/she must do to prove CL either way...

[RandomCommander]

As always, i have to make a very random guess and probably get it wrong...

So i am leaning towards Wesley/Summer/Anandrana/Elmikkino being mafia, since that is one of the lurkers, unless Elmikkino has any objections. Reason being: That spot is lurker-tastic. It had 4 replacements in one game (new record?) and thus making it primely lurker-worthy (unless Elmikkino decides to act).

[ElMikkino]

Well, I'll just start off by saying that I am the doctor. And texasjoshua told me that the previous people had not done any protecting whatsoever. Thus, the mafia are extreme lurkers, and so, we then have a win in the bag, if we can figure out who's lurking the most...wait, that's easy, I just have to search people's usernames in posts.

Moltanem last said something on April 4th, Hyperme on April 8th, and Gigacat on April 9th. Though, that doesn't really help us much, since the last time someone was killed at night was March 6th. I bet that whoever is the mafia was away for a bit, but now that they're probably back, they're just waiting for us to kill each other, as any nightkill now would make too many pointed fingers get flung around.

If you're wondering who I protected last night, it was CheeseLord, but for no reason really other than it didn't really seem to matter who I picked.

I don't have much else to say, except that Anandrana last was here on April 3rd before he/she got replaced. He/she doesn't seem like the person who would know lots about mafia, so if texasjoshua and had notified him/her about them being a mafia, they probably would've killed some random person, but they didn't, which probably means that they, and thus me, are innocent.

Well, that's all I can say to protest my innocence. Right now, I don't have many suspects, but I will random Vote: CheeseLord to get this game moving.

[hyperme]

The first rule of being the doctor is that you don't role claim as the doctor. If you are the doctor, you've moved straight to the top of any hitlists. And also, I've been on, just not saying much. If a was teh mafia, stuff would get done.

Also, I believe that everyone has some kind of power. Given the protecting, healing, copying and mafia-copping, it wouldn't be a stretch to assume everyone is powered. I have a power. No, I'm not saying what it is. So unless there's a normal townie somewhere, this game is power roled to the max.

[Pewskeepski]

Whoa, a doctor claim :shock:

I for one believe Elmikkino. I'm pretty sure he thinks he's safe because of the mafia's inactivity. Also, Wesley (And all those other guys) were lurkers, so it makes sense that nobody was protected.

Other than Wesley, (And all those other guys) bowserfan is the only one who's really been lurking. However, he doesn't post much and when he does, it's usually a short post so I'm not that suspicious of him as he is like this in just about every game.
Also, I believe that everyone has some kind of power. Given the protecting, healing, copying and mafia-copping, it wouldn't be a stretch to assume everyone is powered. I have a power. No, I'm not saying what it is. So unless there's a normal townie somewhere, this game is power roled to the max.
Indeed. Out of the five people who've been killed, only one was an ordinary townie. So remember Mr. Cop, (Who ever you are) if the person you inspect turns out to be an ordinary townie, he could very well be the godfather. You should have inspected 7 people already and if this 'inactive mafia' jazz continues, you should just keep on inspecting until you find all of the mafia, and then post a claim with a list of everybody's roles :)

(Oh, and for any newbies that don't know what I mean by the godfather being inspected: The godfather appears innocent to cops ;))

[CheeseLord]

I can, in fact, confirm that I was protected last night. I'd be willing to guess that ElMikkino is telling the truth.

If the doctor didn't protect anyone on night 2 (back when the mafia was still killing people), I'm curious as to why there was no kill. It's quite possible that the godfather was lurking, but I'd actually be more inclined to believe that he was roleblocked instead. So I'd like to ask who was blocked that night.

Also, Pewskeepski, as a general rule, the cop doesn't get information about the target's role, just the alignment. That does still mean we should be able to figure out two of the mafia.

[ElMikkino]

Thanks for confirming that, CL. And yeah, I only roleclaimed cause of the horrible inactivity on the mafia's part. If it was a regular game, I probably would've just been quiet.

[texasjoshua]

Votes
Cheeselord-1

6 to lynch

[seamonkey]

roleclaim: cop
yeah there has been almost no ev so I have been randomly inpsecting people. MegamanO is mafia.
vote: megamanO (inspections to come)

[seamonkey]

I inspected CL twice - no result. whether it's roleblocking or not I have no idea
Wesley/whatever he is currently innocent
Ima edit in a sec (yeah it's bad, but I'm not hiding anything, just adding)
EDIT megadog is innocent, and I found yourter guilty, but was killed before I could do anything.

[CheeseLord]

For obvious reasons, Vote: MegamanO.

At this point, the cop and the doctor have both claimed, so I see very little reason not to propose a mass roleclaim. I am bulletproof. I wouldn't be entirely surprised if that also translated to inspection-proof. I don't know if I was attacked any of the nights where there was no kill, but I wouldn't be surprised if I was attacked on night 2.

I'd quite like to hear who everyone else is.

[Megadog]

I'm going to listen to SM too, vote: megamanO.

As for my role-claim, I win if the town wins, or if I am alive when the game ends. Don't know the name for this role, but it sounds like an amplified survivor.

[Pewskeepski]

Vote: MegamanO Because I believe all of the above claims.

@CheeseLord: If you're bulletproof, how do you know you've been roleblocked all these nights?

[hyperme]

Vote: MegamanO

I'm lynch proof. This means, will current mafia activity, I cannot die!

[CheeseLord]

Vote: MegamanO Because I believe all of the above claims.

@CheeseLord: If you're bulletproof, how do you know you've been roleblocked all these nights?

I was told in a PM. The same way I knew I was protected last night.

[Pewskeepski]

Here comes my claim!

I am the roleblocker. Yep, it's true, I'm the one blocking CheeseLord. I'm not really suspicious of him but it seemed like blocking him was putting the mafia out of commission. There are a few possibility's that he's mafia, but there are even more possibility's (Some of those possibility's came to my attention today) that he's town. On night 1, SpaceManiac blocked Moltanem (You received a PM?), and blocked CheeseLord on night 5. Once he was replaced by me, I decided to block CheeseLord again just to see what would happen. And then the whole 'anti-night kill' business went on from there.

My original plan was to not block CheeseLord one of these nights and see what would happen. Right now, my suspicions of there being a lurking mafia team are totally confirmed. Hmm... now I don't know who to block :)

[RandomCommander]

Roleclaim: Im just able to PM Molt, nuthin much.

However, we haven't PMed eachother at all, ever, in this whole game :/

My vote: MegamanO

Edit: That's six votes, LYNCHIFY!!!

[Pewskeepski]

Roleclaim: Im just able to PM Molt, nuthin much.

However, we haven't PMed eachother at all, ever, in this whole game :/

My vote: MegamanO

Edit: That's six votes, LYNCHIFY!!!

So you're a mason?

[texasjoshua]

And Random Commander gives the final vote! MegamanO is embargoed!
MegamanO is killed! He is an invading country. He has no special powers.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .

Dead Players
-HammerUp!
-Pewskeepski
-Julian
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.
We are sorry but .Yellow Wizard has not replaced Gigacat, A clerical error has been made. We apologize for any confusion.


It is now Night 8: day will begin on April 26th.

[texasjoshua]

No Country's have been invaded and several minor nations from defensive pacts with larger nations.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-Bowserfan
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .

Dead Players
-HammerUp!
-Pewskeepski
-Julian
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.



It is now Day 8: night will begin on May 3rd.

5 to lynch.

[RandomCommander]

No Country's have been invaded and several minor nations from defensive pacts with larger nations.

Whaddya mean by that!?

[Pewskeepski]

I'd just like to say that I blocked CheeseLord again last night. I wanted to determine whether or not the mafia were just trying to frame him.

Anywho, my immediate suspicion goes to Bowserfan and Moltanem because they are lurking. They weren't lurking at the beginning of this game, and that was when the mafia were invading :roll:

I'd like to wait for everybody to state what they did last night before I cast my vote.

[seamonkey]

I inspected bowserfan and got no result.

[seamonkey]

sorry for the double post, but assuming correct role claims, there are two mafia among bowserfan, gigacat and hyperme. I'm not thinking th best so I could be mistaken though.

[Gigacat]

I here, sorry for lurking, i didnt realise that i was.

[RandomCommander]

Molt is definitely not mafia since me and him are masons. My guess would probably be hyperme. He wasn't lurking when the mafia stopped invading, but was still being rather suspicious.

[texasjoshua]

Whaddya mean by that!?

Just for story lines sake.

[hyperme]

I've already claimed as a lynch proof.

Anyhow, I'd go for the lurkers to. Since if I was evil, stuff would be getting done, we can, via process of elimination, assume bowserfan is a evil person.

VOTE: bowserfan

If he turns out good, I'd say lynch Cheeselord. Constant blocking + no kils could mean mafianess.

[RandomCommander]

Since the mafia IS lurking, i would suggest that Pew could unblock CL?

but we can lynch both, yes.

VOTE: bowserfan

[CheeseLord]

Sounds reasonable enough to me. Vote: bowserfan. I'd also suggest, just as proof of concept, lynching hyperme. If he's telling the truth, we lose nothing, and if he's not, then we've probably found a mafia.

[texasjoshua]

Votes
-Bowserfan-3

[Pewskeepski]

I think that seamonkey should inspect either Moltanem or Gigacat, I'd prefer the latter because it could be unlikely that molt is a mafia mason. If one of them comes up as mafia, we lynch 'em.

Vote: Bowserfan

[moltanem2000]

Boeuf. Sorry for lurking completely, completely forgot about this. which of course doesn't look great for me, but I can confirm that I am a mason and can converse with Random Commander. He already claimed, so there isn't much going back.

I agree with voting lurkers, they're not doing anything anyways, and it's looking increasingly likely that the mafia is one of them. I'm not going to vote bowserfan right away, but I'm definitely going to consider it.

(in other news, I'm gone most of tomorrow, so don't expect a response then)

[Gigacat]

Role Claim!

Im claiming because Im one of 2 or 3 people who havn't claimed yet, and one of them is belived to be mafia. I know its not me so I am gonna prove it by post'in here. I am a bulletproof townie, which means i cant get night killed. Which adds another aspect to the whole why-is-no-one-dieing-from-night-kills thing. mabye the mafia attempted to kill me on one of the nights. meh, whatever.

Im gonna Vote: Bowserfan. My immidiate suspicion is Cheeselord, obviously. pewskeepski, who has claimed as the Roleblocker, has stated that he was blocking CL but im not sure why CL said that he was being blocked. Things that i think could be happening here:
1) CheeseLord is the mafia godfather. On the no kill nights, he got blocked by pewskeepski and thus made no kill.
2) The mafia are trying to frame Cheeselord. Cheeselord did get blocked, but he is not the mafia and the mafia are trying to make it look like CL is the mafia. Which would make me the mafia :p because of my outburst yestermafiaday when I voted CL.
3) Pewskeepski is a mafia roleblocker. he did block Cheeselord, but he is trying to frame Cheeselord and thus kill one of the towns most valuable players. Very Unlikly IMO.
4) WIFOM for all of the above.

I also agree that we kill Hyperme, as it makes perfect sense, as we wouldnt lose a townie if he is turuthful but we would get a mafia if he is lieing.

End Post

[CheeseLord]

Role Claim!

Im claiming because Im one of 2 or 3 people who havn't claimed yet, and one of them is belived to be mafia. I know its not me so I am gonna prove it by post'in here. I am a bulletproof townie, which means i cant get night killed. Which adds another aspect to the whole why-is-no-one-dieing-from-night-kills thing. mabye the mafia attempted to kill me on one of the nights. meh, whatever.

Im gonna Vote: Bowserfan. My immidiate suspicion is Cheeselord, obviously. pewskeepski, who has claimed as the Roleblocker, has stated that he was blocking CL but im not sure why CL said that he was being blocked. Things that i think could be happening here:
1) CheeseLord is the mafia godfather. On the no kill nights, he got blocked by pewskeepski and thus made no kill.
2) The mafia are trying to frame Cheeselord. Cheeselord did get blocked, but he is not the mafia and the mafia are trying to make it look like CL is the mafia. Which would make me the mafia :p because of my outburst yestermafiaday when I voted CL.
3) Pewskeepski is a mafia roleblocker. he did block Cheeselord, but he is trying to frame Cheeselord and thus kill one of the towns most valuable players. Very Unlikly IMO.
4) WIFOM for all of the above.

I also agree that we kill Hyperme, as it makes perfect sense, as we wouldnt lose a townie if he is turuthful but we would get a mafia if he is lieing.

End Post

Odd that you didn't mention being bulletproof immediately after I claimed. That's the ideal moment to counterclaim, and you have posted between then and now, so you've clearly had time to do so.

Also, you seem to have missed the possibility of a lurking godfather. That seems far more likely to me.

[RandomCommander]

There is also a possibility (though rare) of two bulletproof townies, but it is also a tad suspicious that CL is suggesting something that would harm his position otherwise.

So i believe the townie hit list goes like this:

Lynchworthy (Going to die soon):
- Bowserfan
- Hyperme

Suspicious (Keeping our eye on them):
- Cheeselord
- Pewskeepski

Off da hook (Not going to be lynched anytime soon...):
- Gigacat
- Elmikkino
- moltanem2000
- seamonkey
- RandomCommander
- and a few others i have yet to mention...

[texasjoshua]

Votes
Bowserfan-5
1 more to lynch!

[CheeseLord]

There is also a possibility (though rare) of two bulletproof townies, but it is also a tad suspicious that CL is suggesting something that would harm his position otherwise.

What I'm suggesting is that it's virtually impossible that Gigacat is telling the truth. It's impossibly unlikely that there are really two If he was really bulletproof, he would have counterclaimed immediately after I claimed bulletproof. He posted in the meantime, so he clearly had the chance to do so, but he chose not to.

Also, what did I suggest that would harm my position?

[RandomCommander]

What I'm suggesting is that it's virtually impossible that Gigacat is telling the truth. It's impossibly unlikely that there are really two If he was really bulletproof, he would have counterclaimed immediately after I claimed bulletproof. He posted in the meantime, so he clearly had the chance to do so, but he chose not to.

Also, what did I suggest that would harm my position?

I was thinking the other way around. I thought you took the claim of Bulletproof for your own mafia needs, only Gigacat was a bit slow to realize. But then its also clear that you weren't night-killed near the beginning of the game, so therefore being a bulletproof townie seems likely to you then it does Gigacat.

While this is in your favor, you however are still being blocked, meaning two things: 1, if the mafia wasn't lurking, you would have been dead by now. 2, If you aren't bulletproof, then you must be mafia, explaining the no night kills.

You cancel your pros and cons out, while Gigacat had no evidence to offer. Thus, who is the fake is still a mystery.

[Gigacat]

Odd that you didn't mention being bulletproof immediately after I claimed. That's the ideal moment to counterclaim, and you have posted between then and now, so you've clearly had time to do so.

Also, you seem to have missed the possibility of a lurking godfather. That seems far more likely to me.

I didnt add lurking godfather because lots off people already sugested that. but i guess i should still have added it.

Now to the main point: I didnt claim right away because i thought that it would make me look suspicious. If 2 people roleclaimed with the same role, i thought it would look wierd and suspicious. The reason i claim now is because i need to to prove my innocence.

[Megadog]

Back from my 7 day holiday. Probably should have mentioned that but it seems that it didn't matter...

I feel GC is more suspicious than CL, but for now, I will VOTE: BOWSERFAN lurker as well.

[Pewskeepski]

I'm starting to see what CheeseLord is saying and I strongly suggest that seamonkey inspect Gigacat tonight. I don't think Texasjoshua would assign the 'bulletproof' role to more than one person, especially in a game like this where everybody has a unique role.

I made a list of everyones assumed roles and alignments.

-CheeseLord (Bulletproof)
-Elmikkino (Doctor)
-Bowserfan (?)
-Pewskeepski (Roleblocker)
-RandomCommander (Mason)
-Seamonkey (Cop)
-Moltanem2000 (Mason)
-Megadog (Survivor)
-Hyperme (Lynch proof)
-Gigacat. (Bulletproof)

Green = Good
Red = Bad
Purple = Other
Black = Unkown

It's hard to tell which bulletproof guy is telling the truth. CheeseLord could be the godfather being blocked, (By me :mrgreen:) or Gigacat could be mafia unable to make up a role to hide his scumness.

[RandomCommander]

Looks like a winning situation! What is the verdict, Tex?

[texasjoshua]

And its a lynch: Bowserfan is embargoed and his role is reveled. After confronting the Bowerfan. He gives a dramatic speech about how you were wrong and he depended on you all to do the right thing and simply disappeared. No one ever knows where he went or what country he represented but he will play no further action in the events. ( He was night kill proof and town)

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .

Dead Players
-HammerUp!(town)
-Pewskeepski(town)
-Julian(town)
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000(town)
-Bowserfan(town)


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.



It is now Night 9: day will begin on May 4th.

[texasjoshua]

And Once again it appears as though no nations have been invaded.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .

Dead Players
-HammerUp!(town)
-Pewskeepski(town)
-Julian(town)
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000(town)
--Bowserfan(town)


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.



It is now Day 9: night will begin on May 11th.

5 to lynch.[/QUOTE]

[seamonkey]

hyperme is innocent (or teh uninspectable godfatha)

[moltanem2000]

I'd also suggest, just as proof of concept, lynching hyperme. If he's telling the truth, we lose nothing, and if he's not, then we've probably found a mafia.

Sounds good to me. There doesn't seem to be anything more productive to do with our votes at the moment. And of course if he dies and isn't mafia then I guess I'll be mildly suspicious of CL or something.

vote: hyperme

for those who don't remember, Hyperme claimed as lynch-proof.

Also @ Pewskeepski; blocking CL looks like it's been working up until now, so even if it seems unlikely he's mafia, It might be a good idea to continue doing so.

Oh and seamonkey just claimed hyperme may very well be innocent, so if we go ahead with this vote it might be a chance to get some real good info. I also don't recall seamonkey ever really proving his being a cop. so if there is such a post feel free to bring it up.

[RandomCommander]

roleclaim: cop
yeah there has been almost no ev so I have been randomly inpsecting people. MegamanO is mafia.
vote: megamanO (inspections to come)

There's your cop roleclaim!

anywho, I don't think hyperme is of mafianess, but, since molt is deciding to vote him, and seeing that he wouldn't be a heavy loss if we lynch another of our townies, then i guess i should vote him off too.

VOTE: Hyperme

[moltanem2000]

Nah I meant a post where we have solid proof he is a cop, megaman0 did end up being mafia, but there's always the possibility that seamonkey is also mafia and they decided to sacrifice megaman0 in order to make seamonkey look like town.

Of course the whole no night kills in the past 10 years (warning; hyperbole, I am well aware it wasn't 10 years) complicates things immensely, as well as the fact no-one else has claimed cop. but it's still a possibility that I am taking into consideration.

[seamonkey]

Here's my version of what we should do

suspicion:
- Hyperme: No result. quite possibly godfatha, as multiple no lynches and he has been lurky. He has claimed lynch proof, so at worst we lose nobody. at best we kill a mafia. vote:hyperme
- Cheeselord: see above. He's been here so less likely
- moltanem2000: I do see the possibility of a mafia mason.
- RandomCommander: see molt

suspicion, but somehow less:
- Gigacat: don't have much to say here.
- Pewskeepski: I believe CL when he says he's been blocked, and there are no counterclaims
- Elmikkino: no counterclaims. pretty likely in my humble opinion



NOT going to comment on
- seamonkey: Obviously I'm going to say I'm innocent. I could be mafia, but I can't prove myself innocent other than what I'm doing...

[Megadog]

Looks like you forgot me, but you found me innocent in your inspections, so no harm done, I guess...

[texasjoshua]

Votes
Hyperme- 3 Votes
5 to lynch

[Megadog]

Might as well jump on the VOTE: Hyperme to prove he is what he is.

[ElMikkino]

Wait, huh? I don't really get why we are voting hyperme...he was proved innocent; true, he could also be the godfather, but usually you assume that the person is town because its more likely that he is. Godfathers don't even have that power in some games. I'll withhold my vote right now, but I do think it's a bit strange that everyone's agreeing with seamonkey so easily...did I miss something that hyperme said?

[moltanem2000]

Unless someone comes up with a better suggestion as to what to do with our votes, there's no reason not to vote hyperme. So until that happens I'm going with the "prove hyperme is actually lynch-proof" method. (though he might be a jester come to think of it).

anyways, 2 things;

1) @seamonkey Yeah I thought about that after randomcommander claimed for both of us out of nowhere (which I'm mildly upset about btw, I mean, we're masons, you could have talked to me about it). though technically being mafia automagically makes you a mason as well

2) I still haven't found any 100% solid evidence seamonkey is really a cop, so again, until I do find some or someone else finds some for me, I'm going to take everything he says with a grain of salt. (again, if such a post does exist, then ignore this completely and please bring it up so we can settle this.)

[seamonkey]

yeah it'd be bad not to take what I say with a grain of salt, but I really can't prove myself innocent

[hyperme]

Wait, huh? I don't really get why we are voting hyperme...he was proved innocent; true, he could also be the godfather, but usually you assume that the person is town because its more likely that he is. Godfathers don't even have that power in some games. I'll withhold my vote right now, but I do think it's a bit strange that everyone's agreeing with seamonkey so easily...did I miss something that hyperme said?

Lynch me! It proves seamonkey is cop. And then we can work from there.

[RandomCommander]

Well, seamonkey WAS correct about megaman0 being mafia, which actually gives him a high chance of truthfully being a cop. Keeping that in mind, no one has roleclaimed against him, which proves him even more innocent (but i might be wrong about that). I think we should trust seamonkey.

[Megadog]

Well, seamonkey WAS correct about megaman0 being mafia, which actually gives him a high chance of truthfully being a cop. Keeping that in mind, no one has roleclaimed against him, which proves him even more innocent (but i might be wrong about that). I think we should trust seamonkey.
Mafia know who the mafia are.

[RandomCommander]

Mafia know who the mafia are.

They do. Its just it is unlikely that seamonkey would sacrifice his teammate if he WAS mafia.

[seamonkey]

Actually it's a pretty common tactic. In this case however I think I'm slightly less suspicious than I should be as no night kills are happening.

[ElMikkino]

Okay, since hyperme actually wants to die, I guess I'll Vote: hyperme.

[Pewskeepski]

Vote: Hyperme because It will prove both his innocents and Seamonkey's.

I'm going to keep on blocking CheeseLord for sake of blocking somebody. As of now, we have no leads on who the mafia are.

[texasjoshua]

And the UN votes to Embargo Hyperme's Country. It Passes! After several weeks it appears as though it had no affect on Hyperme's Economy at all!

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme( Under Embargo, but not dead!)
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .

Dead Players
-HammerUp!(town)
-Pewskeepski(town)
-Julian(town)
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000(town)
-Bowserfan(town)


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.



It is now Night 10: day will begin on May 12th.

[texasjoshua]

And once again the invading country's appearer to be lying low, several of you ask yourselves if it is even a world threat anymore. But that's for you to decide!

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .

Dead Players
-HammerUp!(town)
-Pewskeepski(town)
-Julian(town)
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000(town)
--Bowserfan(town)


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.



It is now Day 10: night will begin on May 18th.

5 to lynch.

[seamonkey]

I checked on Molt, and discovered a positive (or negative depending on the way you look at it), and he is not a mafia type mason, but is townie, and it has been confirmed that he is working with random commander

[moltanem2000]

Well I can attest to that. Of course I'm going to point out that seamonkey could have just taken info that was already said; there's no new info there. But at this point I find it unlikely that this is the case. Anyways, it would seem that hyperme was in fact lynch proof, which is good to know.

don't really have any ideas as to what to do next, I'll see what y'all have to say.

[Gigacat]

Vote: No Lynch.

I believe Seamonky so we should just wait for him to inspect a mafia. If the mafia do get a kill, then we should change plans.

[Pewskeepski]

Blocked CL and once again there are no invasions.

I'm thinking either CheeseLord or Gigacat (Because of his claim) are mafia. Since lurkers get replaced in this game, lurking mafia shouldn't be a problem so they're either framing CheeseLord, or CheeseLord is the MGF.

[RandomCommander]

I WOULD suggest having pew unblock cheeselord, but that might make the lurker mafia be un-lurky, and ruin my plan (which is highly unlikely, but i don't want to take the risk.)

So i'll just stay with being neutral and don't lynch anyone...

[ElMikkino]

Vote: No Lynch.

I believe Seamonky so we should just wait for him to inspect a mafia. If the mafia do get a kill, then we should change plans.

This seems like a good plan to me. A long, arduous, boring plan, but one that unless Pew for some reason unblocks CL, it should work.

Vote: No Lynch

[Gigacat]

This seems like a good plan to me. A long, arduous, boring plan, but one that unless Pew for some reason unblocks CL, it should work.

Vote: No Lynch

Why do you say that? If the mafia are lurkers, then we dont need to worry about this. Anyway, has Cheeselord been inspected? If not, then that seems like the best inspection option.

[Pewskeepski]

He has been inspected but Seamonkey got no results (Same with hyperme. Strange.)

[RandomCommander]

He has been inspected but Seamonkey got no results (Same with hyperme. Strange.)

Hyperme was tested by us (he claimed to be lynch-proof), and he is still here (Hyperme IS lynch-proof), so he's innocent. Do we have yet to test CL? I've noticed Pew is still blocking him, and there were no night kills, which might be a pattern and might not, and i also noticed he hasn't posted yet.

It's either him or Gigacat, if we HAVE to lynch, it should be one of them.

But for now, i stand with not lynching until we get further information.

[CheeseLord]

I have no objection to no lynching (aside from the fact that it makes the game drag on longer), so I will Vote: No lynch.

I would recommend inspecting Gigacat tonight. We have conflicting claims, and I've already been inspected without any useful results, so that would probably clear up some confusion.

[Megadog]

VOTE: NO LYNCH

I don't really have any pressing suspicions, so that's good for me.

[texasjoshua]

And with a majority vote no embargo is made.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme( Under Embargo, but not dead!)
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .

Dead Players
-HammerUp!(town)
-Pewskeepski(town)
-Julian(town)
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000(town)
-Bowserfan(town)


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.



It is now Night 11: day will begin on May 17th.[/QUOTE]

[texasjoshua]

Sorry for the delay, finals and all. Anyway, it is once again all quiet.

Players:
Host- texasjoshua
Co-Host-

Players Alive:
-CheeseLord
-Wesley(being replaced)- replaced by: Summer(being replaced):Replaced by:Anandrana: replaced by: Elmikkino
-SpaceManiac(being replaced):replaced by: Pewskeepski
-Reecer 6(being replaced)-replaced by RandomCommander
-Seamonkey
-Moltanem2000
-Megadog
-Hyperme
-Gigacat.

Replacements
-Pumkineater
-.Yellow Wizard .
-Felixrain

Dead Players
-HammerUp!(town)
-Pewskeepski(town)
-Julian(town)
- Yourter12(mafia)
--MegamanO(mafia)
Felixrain(being replaced)- replaced by: BunnyBot5000(town)
--Bowserfan(town)


If anyone reading this wishes to sign up as a replacement feel free to PM me.



It is now Day 11: night will begin on May 24th.

5 to lynch.

[hyperme]

So, who did Roleblocky person block? If it was CheeseLord, we kill him.

If not, we kill Gigacat, as the two have conflicting claims, and CL is worth more.

Of course, he'd be worth more to badguys too, so maybe we should just wipe him out.

[CheeseLord]

I was, in fact, blocked again. Now, we've had an additional night, so I should probably ask what information we gained in the meantime. Who was inspected?

Also, I'm curious how you come to those conclusions, hyperme. Why would my being blocked last night mean any more than my being blocked on the rest? And why would I be worth more to the mafia?

[hyperme]

Since you've apparently been blocked most nights, and there hasn't been any killing, you may be the mafia in charge of the kill.

Also, since you conflict with Gigacat, either one of you could be Mafia. If you are evil, and we kill Gigacat, the mafia still have smart thinking CL on their side.

[Pewskeepski]

Oh wow, I was reading Mafia 10 from the beginning to the end for the sake of old times and three posts get put in here :p

On topic: Yes, I did roleblock CheeseLord again. I'm agreeing with Hyperme because I said pretty much the same thing yesterday...
I'm thinking either CheeseLord or Gigacat (Because of his claim) are mafia. Since lurkers get replaced in this game, lurking mafia shouldn't be a problem so they're either framing CheeseLord, or CheeseLord is the MGF.
That said, I'm all for voting either Gigacat or CheeseLord. But I'm really looking forward to what Seamonkey has to say.

*Waits for the cop*

[RandomCommander]

Conclusions can be drawn if the roleblocker decides to remove the roleblock, for now, this is still a mystery.

But yes, and the verdict is....?

[seamonkey]

I inspect gigacat in heteh evil one vote: gigacat

[Pewskeepski]

Vote: Gigacat

I guess this means CheeseLord is innocent.

[CheeseLord]

Vote: Gigacat.

[Gigacat]

Well... Defense of mah self post. I guess i cant defend my self all that well seeing as: I have the same role as Cheeselord has got and I have been proven guilty. I tell you now that i am not guilty. it isobvious that either Seamonkey or Cheeselord are mafia (or both) as they are teaming up to kill me. Cheeselord by falsley claiming as a bullet proof and Seamonky by pretending to be the cop and say that i am the mafia. Personally, i seriously dont think you will believe me but i hope that you do because I am innocent. When i am killed and you find my innocence out for certain, then you should vote seamonky and cheeeselord because one of them must be mafia. In the vain hope that you will believe me i will Vote: Seamonky

[Megadog]

Thanks for pointing that out. If your good, I'll believe you. Till we know, though, VOTE: GIGACAT

[hyperme]

VOTE: GIGACAT

Yeah, I'm not buying your defense.

But if you are town, we lynch seamonkey.

[RandomCommander]

I would vote Gigacat too, but... Thats the maximum votes!

[Pewskeepski]

On second thought: If Gigacat turns out to be anything other than the godfather, CheeseLord could still be scum. Hmm...

[RandomCommander]

Well, its not likely. In most cases, there are only TWO mafia players, so it is very unlikely.