Mafia Game 3

[Mr.Onion]

Dead/Alive
AtkinsSJ (Mafia)
BlackMyth (Mason)
CoolGuy (Doctor)
Dave Hettel (Villager)
Evil_monkey (Mafia Godfather)
NGSB (Bulletproof Townie)
PurpleKoopa2000 (Mafia)
WackieWatty (Lawyer)



Start discussing! The day will end on next Monday.

[WackieWatty]

Yay! The game has started. :D

Too bad we couldn't get more people....

[Dave Hettel]

Too bad, indeed. Are we being PMed our roles over night, or do those who have special roles were already PMed about it? I just wanted to know, seeing as I've received no PMs.

[Mr.Onion]

Those with special Roles have recieved their PMs. I hope the town uses the power I've givin it wisely.

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

Hi. Not much to say yet, is there?

I'm going back to bed now... OR AM I??? :shock: 8) :shock:

[AtkinsSJ]

The game's off to a slow start so far. Maybe the rest of the town is having a lie-in.

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

A "lie-in" you say...

Perhaps you are implying that the town is "LYING"!!! HE'S OBVIOUSLY A MAFIA! SEIZE HIM AT ONCE...

[AtkinsSJ]

Someone is certainly a little edgy. :roll:

[blackmyth]

Vote to Lynch NGSB, it's a gut feeling (wow was that suspicious of me or what? :shock: ).

[Dave Hettel]

Hey, let's just go with the bandwagon.

Vote to lynch Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy

[WackieWatty]

Hey people, we haven't even heard from all of the players yet!

I'm going to leave my vote for a while longer....

[AtkinsSJ]

All aboard the bandwagon!
Vote to lynch Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy

[Coolguy]

Okay, I'm posting just to say that I'm here! I'll wait to vote for someone too...

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

Well, everyone's doing it, so why not me?

Vote to lynch Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy

(Actually, in the last 2 posts I made I was just being jocular. Now I am just resigned to the fact that I will be killed. I'm innocent though, I tells you... :roll: )

[blackmyth]

Change my Vote to Lynch AtkinsSJ, I don't believe he was one to jump aboard the bandwagon in the last 2 games. :?

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

There is hope for me yet!

Vote to lynch AtkinsSJ

There is still a good chance I'll get lynched though. If so, then remember my advice: Dave Hettel and AtkinsSJ are probably Mafia, because they jumped on the bandwagon so quickly. I'm pretty sure that Blackmyth is innocent. Why would he leave the bandwagon if he was a Mafia?

[AtkinsSJ]

Maybe that's what blackmyth wants you to think.

And blackmyth, 1: Spisboy had already been trying to accuse me after doing nothing wrong, 2: I've learnt a lot about playing from the last games, and 3: You accused Spisboy originally, and now you're accusing me. You certainly seem to be pointing the finger a lot.

Vote to lynch blackmyth

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

So at this point,
-1 person is voting for me
-1 person is voting for Blackmyth
-2 people are voting for AtkinsSJ

...Wohoo I'm saved! :D Anyway, I find it very unlikely that Blackmyth could be a Mafia. He created a bandwagon randomly, and a bunch of people joined him. If he was Mafia, he would have stayed with it, but instead he changed his vote to AtkinsSJ. (based on at least a bit of logic)

[Coolguy]

Atkins and Dave Hettel seem suspicious, because I think a mafia would vote as fast as they could in order to get someone else blamed and live another day. I don't think Blackmyth is a mafia. He changed his vote a lot in the last game too.

As for now, I'll keep waiting. We still have two more people!

[PurpleKoopa]

Dave Hettel does seem suspicious... Last time, he was a detective/mason, so he could be a mafia this round. They don't want people to be the same thing over and over again. So...

Vote to lynch Dave Hettel

[blackmyth]

Seeing as it's fairly obvious Dave and Atkins are mafia, I suggest PK changes his vote to Atkins so that we may have more votes on a single mafia, rather then scattered votes on two. :wink:

[WackieWatty]

I'll go with the crowd, (along with a little brotherly love :wink: )

Vote to lynch AtkinsSJ

[AtkinsSJ]

I think PurpleKoopa's right. I thought the Dave was trying to mislead us when he said he'd gotten no PMs.
Vote to lynch Dave Hettel

[Dave Hettel]

They don't want people to be the same thing over and over again.
Quick question: what do you base this on?

Well, since another innocent villager is likely to be killed today anyway, I'll vote for him.

Vote to lynch Dave Hettel

When I am killed, and it is revealed I am a villager, you townies will all regret your decision.

[WackieWatty]

Now why would Dave be voting for himself if he were the mafia?

Unless that's what he wants us to think.... :?

[AtkinsSJ]

Well, Spisboy did the same. Maybe it's something in the water.

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

:? I knew there was something funny about that water...
I think Dave Hettel is a little is a bit suspicious,

Vote to lynch Dave Hettel

I'm partially doing this because AtkinsSJ always died so early in the last few games, I want to see his life prolonged. (Well, last time it was me that killed him anyway... :roll: )

[Coolguy]

Vote to Lynch Dave Hettel

Dave Hettel's very suspicious... especially since he edited his post against the rules and "You townies will all regret your decision!" sounded really mafia-like.

[AtkinsSJ]

That's 5 votes for Dave, making it the majority vote.

[WackieWatty]

But the chances of one of those 5 people being a mafia is high.
Why would a mafia vote for another mafia?

[PurpleKoopa]

But the chances of one of those 5 people being a mafia is high.
Why would a mafia vote for another mafia?
They probably wouldn't, but maybe they would want to delay suspicions, or just shut him up because he's giving out clues. That, and Hettel voted for himself, and we have four people that haven't voted for him. Hmmm.

[Mr.Onion]

There are 4 votes directed to Dave. You cannot vote for yourself.

[Dave Hettel]

OK, I take back my vote then. Somebody else vote for me, so I can just die already!

[WackieWatty]

Well, at the moment there are 4 voting for Dave and 2 voting for AtkinsSJ.

Unless you really want to die, why not vote for AtkinsSJ too??? :)

[Dave Hettel]

Whatever.

Vote to lynch AtkinsSJ

[blackmyth]

AtkinsSJ is definetely a guilty party. :?

They don't want people to be the same thing over and over again.
Dave had a good response to this, and I wholeheartedly agree (although I might be playing into a trap he could be setting, although Atkins is way more suspicious), and one example to prove PK wrong is me. I haven't been a mafia once (and tonight, when a mafia guns me down, this will be proven).

[WackieWatty]

Dave had a good response to this, and I wholeheartedly agree (although I might be playing into a trap he could be setting, although Atkins is way more suspicious), and one example to prove PK wrong is me. I haven't been a mafia once (and tonight, when a mafia guns me down, this will be proven).

Maybe PK is also a mafia?!? :?

[AtkinsSJ]

Maybe YOU'RE a mafia, WW. You don't seem to care much who dies.

Where's Evil_Monkey, anyway? He hasn't posted at all this game.

[Coolguy]

Hmmm... so many suspicions! I hope that our cop might help us tonight.

[blackmyth]

Dave had a good response to this, and I wholeheartedly agree (although I might be playing into a trap he could be setting, although Atkins is way more suspicious), and one example to prove PK wrong is me. I haven't been a mafia once (and tonight, when a mafia guns me down, this will be proven).

Maybe PK is also a mafia?!? :?
Which would make him and Dave Hettel a tie for the second mafia...
EDIT: I forgot to mention, there will obviously only be 2 Mafia in this game (giving the townies a chance), so all 3 cannot be mafia (but Atkins is definite Mafia ;)).
EDIT 2: Where's Evil_Monkey, anyway? He hasn't posted at all this game.
He hasn't posted anywhere else either, indicating that he has not been able to access a computer/internet.

[Mr.Onion]

There are 3 mafia. I will leave you to figuire out how the villagers have aproximatly 45% chance of winning, should they use their tools correctly.

[WackieWatty]

We haven't heard from Evil_monkey yet.

You never know, he may be the third mafia, not Dave! :?

[PurpleKoopa]

We haven't heard from Evil_monkey yet.

You never know, he may be the third mafia, not Dave! :?

Could be. We haven't seen Evil_monkey ANYWHERE yet...he hasn't posted in awhile either! Mr. Onion, maybe we need someone to replace him, another player, perhaps... :?

[blackmyth]

There are 3 mafia. I will leave you to figuire out how the villagers have aproximatly 45% chance of winning, should they use their tools correctly.
O.O

[Dave Hettel]

So, is somebody going to change his or her vote, or am I going to continue to sit on the brink of death for even more time?

[Coolguy]

Wackywattie is getting really suspicious- it keeps sounding like he's protecting Dave Hettel!

[blackmyth]

He's probably trying to get more votes for the mafia we want to go first (Atkins), not protecting Dave. You might ask 'Why does it matter which mafia goes first?'. I, myself, am 68% sure that Dave is a mafia, I remember in the last game he voted for an innocent to keep the game going.

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

I, myself, am 68% sure that Dave is a mafia,

You seem to like coming up with exact statistics out of nowhere. (I'm not criticizing or accusing you, I just think it's kind of funny. :wink: )

[Dave Hettel]

I remember in the last game he voted for an innocent to keep the game going.
But how would what happened in an entirely different game suggest that I am a mafia this game?

[AtkinsSJ]

Maybe blackmyth is getting a little paranoid.

[WackieWatty]

Wackywattie is getting really suspicious- it keeps sounding like he's protecting Dave Hettel!

I just have stronger views of AtkinsSJ being a mafia over Dave!

At the start, it is easier if we all choose one mafia to try to get rid of, rather than spreading the votes. :?

[blackmyth]

I remember in the last game he voted for an innocent to keep the game going.
But how would what happened in an entirely different game suggest that I am a mafia this game?
I'm just saying that you COULD have jumped on the bandwagon for the sake of lynching somebody, although it might not be entirely true.

You seem to like coming up with exact statistics out of nowhere. (I'm not criticizing or accusing you, I just think it's kind of funny. ;) )
Well I wanted a percantage that seemed close to high, but near to half sure, and this seemed about right.

EDIT: At the start, it is easier if we all choose one mafia to try to get rid of, rather than spreading the votes.
Exactly what I was saying earlier. :wink:

[AtkinsSJ]

The only reason WackieWatty is trying to get me lynched is because I'm his brother.
I don't know why people keep accusing me of being a Mafia when there's little proof, but if you want to kill a townie, go for it.

[Dave Hettel]

I mean, I'm not like encouraging you to kill me, but shouldn't somebody actually be acting on their instincts by changing his or her vote, or are all of you just going to keep talking about this?

[WackieWatty]

The only reason WackieWatty is trying to get me lynched is because I'm his brother.
I don't know why people keep accusing me of being a Mafia when there's little proof, but if you want to kill a townie, go for it.

I'm just agreeing with what some of the others have said.

And you're not one to go along with what others think??? :?

Edit: I know that it's a bit late now, but we really need someone to replace Evil_monkey!

[WackieWatty]

So, has the day ended now?

[PurpleKoopa]

I think it ends when Mr.Onion posts who gets killed off. So, in other words, no.

[Mr.Onion]

"GLURK!" were Dave Hettel lasts words as he was lynched. It is Night. Dave was a villager.

[AtkinsSJ]

Dave was a townie? Oh...

[WackieWatty]

Don't say I didn't warn you, people!

[PurpleKoopa]

Darn! At least he wasn't a detective or doctor. Rest in peace, Dave.

[Dave Hettel]

Yeah, I said it was coming and you ignored me. I'm hoping the mafia win now just to show you what you've done.

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

Don't be so bitter, Dave, we just made a mistake. We're really sorry we killed you, honest... :(

[WackieWatty]

Well, I was right about Dave, and I hope to be right again....

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

Isn't it night right now? You are staying up way past your bedtime, people! Especially since it's 666 day...

[Dave Hettel]

Well, I was right about Dave, and I hope to be right again....
Well if you were right about me why didn't you change your vote?

Anyways. The undead have no bedtime. If you don't mind I'm going to hang around the town square terrorizing passersby. :P

[Chris Da Lunatic]

What's mafia??

[PurpleKoopa]

Wikipedia knows. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mafia_%28game%29)

[puffazoid]

yes, i know i'm not part of the game (yet)... but can we please move along? this is geting repetitive. kill someone already! :evil:

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

It is night right now and no one is supposed to post until the mafia and special townies pm their decisions to Mr.Onion. That is why no one is voting yet.

[Mr.Onion]

"You don't have to sit around complaining about the way that luck decieved you."


Blackmyth was assasinated. He was a Mason. It is Day.

[WackieWatty]

I just had a look throught the last game, and I understand all the rules properly now. :roll:

[AtkinsSJ]

Gosh, Blackmyth's dead.

[PurpleKoopa]

WackieWatty looks suspicious...eager to point the finger...however, I won't vote yet. I'll wait for other people.

[blackmyth]

It seems whenever I get close to a mafia (see last game) I get assassinated. I hope everybody learns from this. ;) *Joins Dave at the Town Square.*

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

The obvious question is "who would want to have Blackmyth lynched?"

One reason is that Blackmyth was being pretty logical. However, he also accused AtkinsSJ a lot, and he was a mason so he probably knew what he was talking about. AtkinsSJ has been acting a little suspicious. For example:
Gosh, Blackmyth's dead.
What is up with that?

Vot to lynch AtkinsSJ

[AtkinsSJ]

So what? I merely made an exclamation of surprise.

And anyway, what if the mafia killed blackmyth because they knew people would think it was me. Maybe you're the mafia, and you're trying to make me look suspicious.

Vote to lynch Nebro-Gubular Spisboy

[WackieWatty]

Blackmyth was a mason, and so nobody who voted the same way as him should be a mafia.
Dave ended up voting the same way. He was found out to be a villager.
I also voted the same way, as I am the other MASON

So I still believe that we all need to Vote to lynch AtkinsSJ

[PurpleKoopa]

Now, couldn't anybody go and say they're a so and so?

I'm going to Vote to lynch Nebro-Gubular Spisboy. Remember how defensive he was in the last game? He could just be not trying to harm his mafia cohorts.

[WackieWatty]

Now, couldn't anybody go and say they're a so and so?



That's what you say. But would I really vote to try and lynch one of the mafia, just to rule myself out?

[AtkinsSJ]

Hmmm. We're deadlocked, because the other 2 players aren't playing. :roll:
Come on, Wackie! If you saw the last game, you'd know how decieving Spisboy can be. We must get rid of him, for the sake of the town!

[blackmyth]

Now, couldn't anybody go and say they're a so and so?
*Paper falls out of back pocket with 'WackieWatty is the other Mason' written on it.* :wink:

EDIT: This game cannot be won by either party, unless only the last mafia comes and votes for NGSB, or if only the last townie comes and votes for Atkins. And if both the last mafia and last townie come back and vote for NGSB/Atkins, then we'll still be in the same predicament. (Unless 2 people can be lynched, because the mafia will gun somebody down during the night, and they will be victorious.)=/ Also, check this out:
I haven't been a mafia once (and tonight, when a mafia guns me down, this will be proven).
I was right wasn't I? :lol:

[WackieWatty]

Coolguy may come back on, but I doubt that Evil_monkey will ever join this game.

[WackieWatty]

Sorry to double post, but....

If a mafia isn't voted off today, then all us villagers are in a lot of trouble. :?

[Mr.Onion]

Where are you, Coolguy and Evil_monkey?

@Blackmyth, The Dead are not supposed to reaveal roles of anyone minus themselves. Do so again and I will disqualify you.

[PurpleKoopa]

Mr.Onion, have you tried PMing them?

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

Coolguy may come back on, but I doubt that Evil_monkey will ever join this game.

Let's just hope that Evil_Monkey is the Mafia and not Coolguy.

[blackmyth]

@Blackmyth, The Dead are not supposed to reaveal roles of anyone minus themselves. Do so again and I will disqualify you.
It would have been nice if you had told me that in the last game. :wink:

[Mr.Onion]

<censored>, I forgot. The random lynch is ATKINSJ! He is a MAFIA!!! It is Night.


BTW, Could the mafia please PM me and say who they think the other mafia are?

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

What? A random lynch? TWO mafias?

At least I know I was right about a certain fat crow... The fact that there is more than one mafia, however, complicates things. We know that the people who voted for AtkinsSJ are either townies or people in the other mafia. Hmm... :?

[Coolguy]

Okay, I'd like to say that I'm still alive!

Vote to lynch PurpleKoopa

He is the only person who hasn't voted Atkins, besides Evil Monkey and me.

[PurpleKoopa]

Maybe I just had a suspicion about him...

Just a reminder, it's night, so we don't lynch people off yet! Get your PMs in!

[Coolguy]

Oh, sorry :( ! We'll get that mafia in the morning, though!

[WackieWatty]

I'll probably get lynched off tonight by the mafia because I'm a mason.
But at least Coolguy is back in the game, it looks like he's a villager, so it'll be (after tonight) one active mafia against 2 villagers. (Unless Evil_monkey comes back on. In which case the mafia will end up winning. :wink: )

[Mr.Onion]

It is Day. The Mafia shooting tonight FAILED! The intended target was Nebro-Gubular Spis-Boy, but he was protected. Start lynching.

[WackieWatty]

So, people, which mafia are we gonnna lynch off today?

We have the upper hand with 3 villagers against 2 mafia!

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

YES! :D 8) Ha ha ha, Mafia-men! I SURVIVED! Ha! What now? Eh? Now everyone knows that I'm innocent! Your assasination plan backfired!

Also, thank you, doctor, for saving my life. I love you, mysterious doctor!

Now, who shall we lynch... I have to look over the posts for the moment, than I will vote.

[WackieWatty]

Well, the only mafia who is posting this game is PurpleKoopa2000 :)

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

I agree.

Vote to lynch PurpleKoopa2000

[WackieWatty]

Unless Evil_monkey comes back on, PurpleKoopa will be outnumbered!! :twisted:

Vote to lynch PurpleKoopa2000

[PurpleKoopa]

Hopping on a band wagon, eh? And do you know I'm a mafia, or are you just thinking it? Your claim is very unresonable, Mr. Watty.

[Coolguy]

Vote to lynch Purplekoopa2000
*see above*

[WackieWatty]

Hopping on a band wagon, eh? And do you know I'm a mafia, or are you just thinking it? Your claim is very unresonable, Mr. Watty.

Well if there are 3 voting for you now, and 2 not, then at least one of us would need to be a villager. But that would mean that you and Evil_monkey were also villagers.... :?

But, you never voted for AtkinsSJ, and AtkinsSJ never voted for you. He was a mafia. :wink:

Also, I am a mason and Nebro-Gubular Spisboy is a villager. SO we can't be the mafia.

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

As it says in my sig, I will disappear from now until next Saturday. Sorry, I hope this does not hamper the townies' chances of winning...

[PurpleKoopa]

Harrumph. I'm suspecting Coolguy and WackieWatty. Just because I was wrong doesn't mean I'm a mafia.

[Coolguy]

WW is a mason. NGSB was targetted by the mafia. And finally, I am the doctor! You have to be the mafia. Mr. Onion said that there was 3 mafia. We already lynched one, and the only people who haven't been confirmed to be townies are you and Evil Monkey.

Finally, the townies will win!

[PurpleKoopa]

You're brushing me away like nothing. You have to be hiding something, Coolguy.

Vote to lynch Coolguy

[Coolguy]

I am the doctor

[PurpleKoopa]

Now, couldn't anybody go and say they're a so and so?

[blackmyth]

Let's just get on with the game!!!

[Mr.Onion]

That is a 3/5 majority. It is Night. PurpleKoopa200 was lynched. He was Mafia!

[Coolguy]

I don't think Evil Monkey is going to come back on, if he's the last mafia.

[PurpleKoopa]

Purple Koopa has one last gasp - "Bwahaha! You've fought well, townies! Seeing how the end is nigh for us mafia, I'll just say for now...good game!"

[Mr.Onion]

Coolguy was shot. He was the Doctor. It is Day. There is one mafia remaining.

[WackieWatty]

Coolguy was shot. He was the Doctor. It is Day. There is one mafia remaining.

So Evil_monkey must have come back on then??? :?

Anyway, Vote to lynch Evil_monkey

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

I'm back! And just in time! 8)

Vote to lynch Evil_Monkey

[Mr.Onion]

Evil_monkey said his last words, they were: "Zeeky Boogy Doog!" Thus, there was a nuclear explosian which wiped out the village.

THE VILLAGE WIN!!!


http://i63.photobucket.com/albums/h150/Bit-map/9cf0db18.png

[Dave Hettel]

Nice. You've done a good job, townies.

BTW, what's Bullet Proof?

[Nebro-Gubular SpisBoy]

Yeah, I said it was coming and you ignored me. I'm hoping the mafia win now just to show you what you've done.
Who's a resentful pessimist now, eh?

WOOHOO! TOWNIES WIN! YOU CAN TELL I AM VERY HAPPY BECAUSE I AM POSTING IN ALL CAPITALS!

BTW, bullet-proof means I can't be shot because I am a superhuman bulletproof genius. I don't know what lawyer is, though.

[PurpleKoopa]

The Lawyer (alternatively Stool Pigeon) is an Innocent who knows the identities of the Mafia before the game starts, and works to get them lynched. This role can be extremely broken if a restriction is not put on its claiming.

[WackieWatty]

Oh, so that's why I knew who the mafia were?!?! :roll:

I tried not to give my knowledge away too much.... :oops: